10 Best Egg Crate Mattress Topper: Ultimate Buying Guide (2024 Update)

Whether your old mattress is feeling a little tired, or your new mattress isn’t as comfy as you’d like, choosing a mattress topper is an obvious solution. All you need to do is pick the cheapest and you’ll instantly have sweet dreams, right?

Well, that’s not always the case. Finding a mattress topper isn’t simple. To start with, you need to choose a type. In this guide and review comparison article, we are looking at egg crate mattress toppers.

There are a few reasons why they’re so popular! We’ll explain exactly why you’ll love an egg crate mattress top below, plus take you through the 10 best-rated toppers for 2022.

Why We Love Egg Crate Mattress Pads

Egg crate toppers are named as such due to their appearance. They look like card or plastic egg crates, but they’re actually made of memory foam. This weird bumpy surface looks uncomfortable, but when made from memory foam it’s actually extremely good for your body.

An egg crate mattress topper is:

• Good for all sleeping positions, whether you lay on your back, side, or stomach.
• Available in a range of prices, so don’t sweat if you have a tight budget!
• Usually made from memory foam or other foam, which is often hypoallergenic (although not particularly great for the environment).
• Regulates airflow, as the bumpy texture allows air to flow through the mattress.
• Designed to relieve pressure, which is great for bed-ridden patients… or anyone who spends all day watching Netflix in bed!
• Many egg crate mattresses are durable and designed to last as long as your mattress – or even outlast it. Check the durability rating on all our toppers below to compare them.
• Any mattress topper will extend the life of your mattress by protecting it from spills and damage.
• Furthermore, if the topper is damaged or gets stained, it’s much easier to clean it or replace it compared to cleaning or replacing a full mattress.

That’s eight great reasons to check out egg crate mattress toppers. Our list below will cover some of the highest-rated egg crate toppers for you to browse.

We highly recommend that you give one a test try, at least. Many of the cheap mattress toppers won’t cost much at all, but they’ll give you an idea of what it feels like to sleep on one. Some of the more expensive toppers come with guarantees and even trial nights, so you can return them if you don’t like them.

By trying an egg crate mattress topper, you have very little to lose. According to the American Sleep Association, over 30% of Americans are sleep deprived and this can lead to some pretty serious accidents and health conditions. If you could remedy that with a simple mattress topper, shouldn’t you at least try?

How We Researched These Toppers

To start with, we only looked at mattress toppers that have a proven track record. That means each topper below is created by a respectable and reputable brand that offers a warranty and a returns policy. You can trust them!

The key features you want to analyze are:

Material
Memory foam is the most commonly used material, which is fine. You’ll want to look for confirmation that it’s hypoallergenic and has been tested for safety. Certifications from Oeko-Tex and CertiPUR-US are desirable.

Durability and Lifetime
Some of the best toppers come with guarantees and estimates of how long they will last. This is a good sign and you should always compare them. This is also a good indicator of manufacturing quality.

Special Features
Trademarked technologies and flashy features might sound great, but they only matter if they are effective. When you start comparing mattress toppers, you might realize that those special features were actually pretty standard.

Common features to spot include:

• Firm base layers,
• Gel-infused tips,
• Zoned areas and unusual designs.

You should also read through the reviews for a product. Look at Amazon, Consumer Reports, Feefo, and online forums to get a whole picture and spot any fake reviews. Things like comfort and delivery delays are very personal, so don’t be put off by the odd negative customer review. However, a pattern of reviews that are concerned with build quality and longevity, for example, might be more of a concern.

Last but not least, check the returns policy on the topper before you buy it. After your research, you should be pretty confident, but it’s always better to be safe than sorry!

10 Best Egg Crate Mattress Toppers: Detailed Reviews

These are the top 10 egg crate mattress toppers that we’ve had the pleasure of evaluating. Scroll down to read the full list, starting with the overall best, or read our research below. If you plan to find your own mattress topper that isn’t mentioned on our list, then our specific research points will tell you exactly what you should be looking for.

1. ZINUS 1.5-inch Cooling Gel Egg Crate Mattress Topper: Best Overall

This egg crate mattress topper is an all-around pleaser. First, the price is super low which we are sure you will be glad to hear! You can purchase the king-size mattress topper for around $50 (at the time of writing) whereas you’d only be able to afford a twin-size topper at this price range from most other leading brands.

We reviewed and recommended the 1.5-inch topper, which is certainly enough to create a comfortable and relaxing sleep experience. ZINUS also has this cooling gel topper available in 2, 3, and 4-inch thicknesses. If you are a side sleeper or like a seriously soft mattress, then a thicker topper will be preferable.

ZINUS is a fairly well-known brand. This product is CertiPUR-US certified and is made with their “green tea memory foam”. We think this may be just marketing spiel (you cannot see nor detect any green tea) but it’s a very good mattress topper nonetheless.

For a great night’s sleep, it’s an obvious choice.

2. SensorPEDIC 2.5-Inch Charcoal Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper: Best Cooling

This mattress topper is a little more decked out compared to our best overall selection… and you should expect a higher price tag as a result (although this one is often in the sales). The SensorPEDIC charcoal-infused egg crate memory foam mattress topper is our favorite for cooling. If you usually sleep hot or find that memory foam makes you a bit sweaty, then you’ll enjoy the charcoal-infused technology used here.

Egg crate mattresses in general are designed to keep you cool, but the charcoal tips enhance the cooling sensation further. At 2.5 inches, this topper is surprisingly firm too, thanks to the base layer. For that reason, it’s pretty good for those that prefer a firm mattress feel.

The foam is CertiPUR-US certified and if you buy this topper through Target, you shouldn’t have any trouble returning it either (just in case).

3. Linenspa 3-Inch 5-Zone Gel Memory Foam Topper: Best Unusual Design

The zoned areas of this gel memory foam topper are focused on relieving pressure. It’s designed for the average person to lay down and feel supported from head to two, which comes with a few problems.

If you are overly tall or short, you may not align with the zones. Furthermore, if you like to sit up in bed and work, read or watch TV, then it won’t feel that comfortable either. And don’t forget that although this is a gel memory foam, the close peaks and swirls in the design aren’t as good for airflow as traditional egg crate shapes.

But putting those negatives aside, this is actually a highly rated topper that customers love. It’s CertiPUR-US certified with trademark registered foam technologies and a 3-year standard warranty. The comfort is definitely on the soft and plush side!

4. Future Foam Enhance Highloft 3-Inch Memory Foam Topper: Best Soft Feel

When we read the hundreds of reviews online commenting on how soft and comfortable this topper was, we knew we had to give it a go! Future Foam may not be a well-known mattress or bedding brand, but they certainly knew what they were doing when they created this topper.

The 3-inch memory foam is incredibly plush and soft. If you want to feel like you’re sinking into a marshmallow each night, then this is the topper for you. As it’s so sinkable, we recommend it to side sleepers over back sleepers – the softness might not offer the lumbar support you need if you like to sleep on your back.

As this is quite a cheap topper, the quality isn’t amazing. But as long as you handle it delicately, then it should be moderately long-lasting. We like that it is made in the USA and is CertiPUR-US certified.

5. Future Foam Enhance Highloft 2-Inch Memory Foam Topper

Yes, this is virtually identical to the mattress above! Future Foam offers a range of toppers in different thicknesses. We chose the 3-inch thickness as the softest option, while the 2-inch option is our best budget.

This is not the cheapest topper ever, but it’s got that good balance of quality for the price. The 2 inches of foam provide enough softness and support for you to really notice the difference… but they aren’t as cushioning as the thicker topper.

As you’d expect, this egg crate mattress pad also has CertiPUR-US certification and is made in the USA. If you are on a very tight budget and don’t have any desire for a cooling or pressure relief design, then it’s a solid choice.

6. Lucid Gel or Lavender 5-Zone Memory Foam Mattress Topper: Best Zoned Support

Lucid is a respectable and well-known mattress brand with a range of different mattress toppers. This isn’t a true egg crate topper, as it has a swirl of patterns and designs that come in zoned layers that align with your body.

What caught our eye was the two different options you have. There’s the classic gel-infused memory foam which is ideal for anyone who struggles to keep cool at night. But there’s also a cool lavender-infused topper.

This sounds like a good idea – it will release lavender scents as you snooze. However, we can’t speak for the longevity of the scent and from experience, we predict it will probably wear off after a short period. That’s why the gel version is the best option.

You can also layer up these toppers, to create a 4-inch topper that provides extra comfort. Both versions of the topper come with a 3-year warranty.

7. Sure2Sleep Zoned Memory Foam Mattress Topper

We had seen the Sure2Sleep mattress topper on a few “best” lists, but we aren’t entirely convinced. After researching, evaluating, and comparing it to other brands, we couldn’t see what all the hype was about. So, that’s why it hasn’t earned any awards on our list.

Nonetheless, it is a decent mattress topper, and don’t be afraid to try it out if the previous mattress toppers didn’t work out for you. It is available in 2-inch and 3-inch thicknesses and has 5 zones that should provide more support than a standard foam layer. There’s no cooling gel or charcoal infusion, so you’re relying on air ventilation to keep you cool at night.

It’s made in the USA with CertiPUR-US certified materials, plus it comes with a 30-night trial and 3-year standard warranty.

8. Rest Haven 3-Inch Gel Egg Crate Memory Foam Mattress

This Rest Haven egg crate mattress topper is quite pricey, but it’s justifiable. The 3-inch memory foam pad is convoluted and gel-infused to ensure a cool sleep every night. You have a 3-year warranty (which is standard in the industry) and the comfort in knowing that the foam is CertiPUR-US certified.

Overall, this topper is soft, cool, and reliable. It doesn’t offer much more than any other egg crate mattress topper on the market, except that when you finally settle down for the night you will realize that the quality is superb.

We’ve ranked the quality as very good and the durability as good. So long as you take good care of this topper (no spills or heavy handling) it should last you a long time – far beyond the 3-year warranty that it comes with.

9. Milliard 2-Inch Egg Crate Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Milliard is a fairly well-known brand in the mattress and bedding world. If you have a baby, you’ve probably already seen their crib-size mattresses and pads. Just like the baby range, this mattress topper is very basic but it works.

We recommend it for anyone who doesn’t need any fuss. Whether you’ll only use the topper once or twice, or it will only go in the spare room, this is a very low-budget option. The quality isn’t great, but if you aren’t moving it around lots or sleeping on it every single night, it should suffice.

The foam itself meets CertiPUR-US standards and has been analyzed by independent testing laboratories for content, emissions, and durability. So while it may not be amazing, you can at least feel confident that it’s safe and healthy to sleep on.

10. Wayfair Sleep 3-Inch Gel Memory Foam Egg Crate Mattress Topper

This is a basic, own-brand mattress topper that comes in the classic egg crate style. You really could load it up with eggs!

Wayfair is a reliable brand and a good alternative to Target and Walmart if you want a little bit more quality. Their mattress is made in the USA from gel-infused memory foam for extra coolness. The CertiPUR-US certified memory foam has a medium comfort level and comes with a 3-year limited warranty. So, all as standard then.

Like most toppers, this one will fit comfortably under a fitted sheet – it doesn’t come with its own cover (although you may be able to buy one separately on Amazon). To clean it, use a cloth or sponge and dab at the stain. It cannot go in the washing machine.

Best Egg Crate Mattress Topper: More FAQs

What is an egg crate mattress topper?

This type of mattress topper has a bumpy geometric shape on the top, much like an egg crate. But don’t worry, it’s actually a very comfy design and will be hidden by your bed sheets anyway.

Why are egg crate mattress toppers good?

Designed to relieve pressure and improve airflow, these mattress toppers are especially comfortable and great for all sleeping positions. Mattress toppers in general are praised for protecting and extending the life of your mattress too.

Do egg crate mattress toppers work?

Yes, a good-quality mattress topper will work. It’s all about finding a good balance of price and quality. You should also look out for extra features, such as cooling gels and alternating zones.

Are egg crate toppers expensive?

No, not necessarily. There are a range of mattress toppers available at different prices. You may even find some available for $20. Egg crate toppers are made by cheap grocery store brands and high-quality mattress brands alike.

How long do egg crate mattress toppers last?

The mattress topper should last a minimum of 3 years, as this is when most manufacturers put the warranty expiration date at. If you take good care of your mattress topper then it could last far longer.

Does egg crate foam prevent bedsores?

Yes, the egg crate foam mattress relieves pressure points which can help to relieve bed sores. It depends on the quality of the foam as well as how much time you spend in bed and the compression of the mattress. This is why egg crate foam toppers are popular with bed-ridden patients.

Is egg crate foam good for a bad back?

It can be, as it relieves pressure points. If you have muscle aches or stress that accumulates in your back and shoulders, then it will be great. However, if you have spinal problems then a firm mattress may be better. Some people even recommend sleeping on a floor mat to improve back problems!

Also Read: 10 Best Mattress Topper For Back Pain 2021

Are egg crate toppers hypoallergenic?

Many are, as they’re made with memory foam. However, it’s wise to never assume a mattress topper is hypoallergenic unless it specifically states that it is!

Where can I buy egg crate toppers?

Like nearly everything these days, you can find egg crate mattress pads on Amazon. You can also find them in general stores such as Target and Nordstrom, and bedding or mattress-specific stores such as Mattress Firm.

Which is the best egg crate mattress topper?

The best egg crate mattress topper we found is the 1.5-inch gel mattress topper by ZINUS. It’s best for quality and comfort, plus it’s available at a pretty reasonable price considering what’s on offer. If you want a thicker mattress that’s a little plusher, check out the 3-inch version of the Future Foam egg crate mattress topper.

Also Checkout:

• 5 Best Latex Mattress Topper in 2021
• Best Organic Mattress Toppers in 2021 ( No VOCs and Other Chemical )